22 January 2013

As Interest in Spiritual Directors Grows, Christians Must Be Wary and Armed with Truth

*This article originally appears here at Christian Research Network.

It seems that men and women often are searching for the next great experience. Whether this is religious or purely carnal, mankind's affinity for the subjective often overwhelms his reason. No doubt this has largely contributed to the popularity of such things as contemplative prayer and other spiritual formation practices among professing Christians. Because many of the elements of spiritual formation have their roots in Roman Catholic mysticism, it comes as no surprise when yet another popular Roman Catholic trend trickles into evangelicalism. Such may be the case with the concept of spiritual direction and spiritual directors.

A recent Christian Post (CP) article states that,
If your resolution this year is to have a better relationship with God, a spiritual director might just help you keep it. (Source)
What CP neglects to mention is that one's faith does not come by means of a spiritual director, but from God Himself (Eph. 2:8–9). Not only that, it is God Who keeps the Christian in his faith (Jude 24), sanctifying him by the power of the Holy Spirit (1 Thess. 5:23; 2 Thess. 2:13). Perhaps a more effective approach to "a better relationship with God" would be for one to seek to know Him through the Word that He has provided.

Nevertheless, to support this statement, CP turns to Roman Catholic Dan Burke, executive director of the National Catholic Register and author of the book, Navigating the Interior Life: Spiritual Direction and the Journey to God. According to the book's website, spiritual direction is
  • Understanding the general direction or trajectory of one’s soul
  • Working with a spiritual guide to help unite one’s soul to God and find peace and joy through the pursuit of His will and ways
  • A process of growing in holiness
Spiritual direction is quite popular within Roman Catholicism, with the Catholic Encyclopedia offering the following:
In the technical sense of the term, spiritual direction is that function of the sacred ministry by which the Church guides the faithful to the attainment of eternal happiness. It is part of the commission given to her in the words of Christ: "Going, therefore, teach ye all nations . . . teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you" (Matthew 28:19 sq.). She exercises this function both in her public teaching, whether in word or writing, and in the private guidance of souls according to their individual needs; but it is the private guidance that is generally understood by the term "spiritual direction". (Source)
The Catholic Encyclopedia further addresses the potential mystical elements of spiritual direction:
Another marked difference in the direction of souls arises from the presence or absence of the mystical element in the life of the person to be directed. Mysticism involves peculiar modes of action by which the Holy Ghost illumines a soul in ways which transcend the normal use of the reasoning powers. (Source)
Once this mystical element is acknowledged, the Christian who relies upon God's Word as the sole source of objective truth must pause in rightful caution. Yet could it be that it is this very appeal to emotional experiences that allows for the growing popularity of spiritual direction, even beyond the so-called Christian realm?

A May 2012 Boston Globe article reported on the growing demand for spiritual directors, noting that many millennials who consider themselves to be "spiritual but not religious" are turning to these individuals for guidance. The article quotes a "young, evangelical Christian" pastrix, Michelle Sanchez, as saying,
“So many religious traditions end up feeling quite divorced from your everyday life and experience, so it’s essentially irrelevant,’’ she said. “I think people are tired of that, and I think they hunger for a God they can experience, that is relevant, and close, and that can actually transform them.’’ (Source)
This article also describes a 25-year-old musician who does not attend church but who will spend an hour every three weeks "with a gentle, bearded man in a quiet room with gleaming oak floors [talking] about the experiences that most awaken her spirit, the people who make her feel most connected and alive."

Spiritual direction may be a way to indulge one's narcissistic tendencies for a time, but should it be something to which the Christian turns to improve his relationship with God?

Spiritual Directors International (SDI) is one of the largest organizations of its kind. A visitor to the SDI website can quickly locate spiritual directors of varying faiths within his own city. The aforementioned Christian Post article even references this organization as a "good place to start" for those who may be seeking spiritual direction. From the SDI website:
Also known as spiritual companions or spiritual guides, spiritual directors help people discover how God is truly with them every day and everywhere. Around the world, spiritual direction is cultivating communities of peace and compassion through the contemplative practice of sacred listening. (Source)
Here again the mystical elements of spiritual direction become evident. The language used here is not unlike that used by proponents of contemplative prayer and spiritual formation. The professing Christian who practices such things often does so under the guise of seeking to "hear from God." Yet, when seeking to “hear from God,” there is no biblical guidance as to how one may determine exactly who or what is communicating. Such practices, then, may open wide a door to supernatural experiences and influence that does not find its origin in God.

Delving further into the SDI website offers additional confirmation that the Christian should not pursue involvement in such activities:
Do you want to be part of a global contemplative movement that contributes to peace, justice, and living in right relationship with all creation? Together we are changing the world through the contemplative action of spiritual direction.... 
Spiritual Directors International is a global learning community of people from many faiths and many nations who share a common passion and commitment to the art and contemplative practice of spiritual direction, known as spiritual companionship, spiritual guidance, anam cara in Gaelic, and mashpiah in Hebrew....

SDI has a vibrant membership of more than six thousand individuals on six continents who represent forty-five spiritual traditions, from Anabaptists to Zen Buddhists and many spiritual traditions in between. Everyone is welcome to join this rich learning community.

It is clear that this is not only a mystical endeavor, but an ecumenical one as well. SDI and its spiritual directors do not appear to seek the change that results when a man repents of his sin and turns to Christ for salvation, but rather seeks to further an agenda of social change through "contemplative action."

One also wonders how it is that spiritual directors of varying faiths can help a person to know "how God is truly with them every day and everywhere"? As Scripture tells us, "There is one God, and there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus" (1 Tim. 2:5).

The Christian ought to know that he cannot unite with other faiths in such endeavors as "spiritual companionship," for in this world there are only two spirits of influence: the Holy Spirit of God and the spirit of antichrist, or Satan. The man whose God is not Jesus Christ will one day discover that his god on this earth was Satan himself, regardless of what name he was called.

It may rightly be deduced that the growing influence of spiritual direction and spiritual directors is yet another means of deception by the father of lies (John 8:44). The gospel presented above to seek a "global contemplative movement" of peace, justice, etc., is not a saving gospel. It offers an ideal example of why it is that the Christian must turn, not to pleasant, fleeting experiences, but to the only word of truth as provided by God in Scripture.
Sanctify them in the truth; your word is truth. (John 17:17)
The sum of your word is truth, and every one of your righteous rules endures forever. (Ps. 119:160)
As the appeal of the concept of a spiritual director is ushered into evangelicalism from Roman Catholicism, let the Christian be ever mindful of Paul's admonition to the Galatians:
But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach to you a gospel contrary to the one we preached to you, let him be accursed. As we have said before, so now I say again: If anyone is preaching to you a gospel contrary to the one you received, let him be accursed. (Gal. 1:8–9)
Further, let the words of Peter, who himself was privy to a great experience in witnessing the Transfiguration, remind of the importance and value of the written Word of God:
For we did not follow cleverly devised myths when we made known to you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but we were eyewitnesses of his majesty. For when he received honor and glory from God the Father, and the voice was borne to him by the Majestic Glory, “This is my beloved Son, with whom I am well pleased,” we ourselves heard this very voice borne from heaven, for we were with him on the holy mountain. And we have the prophetic word more fully confirmed, to which you will do well to pay attention as to a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts, knowing this first of all, that no prophecy of Scripture comes from someone's own interpretation. For no prophecy was ever produced by the will of man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit. (2 Pet. 1:16–21)
The truth of God and the saving gospel of Jesus Christ is contained in His Word. This should not be abandoned for a wild goose chase into one's own mind as guided by a spiritual director. Rather, let the Christian turn to the source, God Himself, for true spiritual direction, boldly approaching His throne in prayer (Heb. 4:16) and eagerly seeking to know Him through His Word. Let His Word be read, taught and proclaimed. It is, after all, through the proclamation of this great Word that men may be saved (Rom. 10:17).

Further Reading
The Influence of Christian Mystics Morton Kelsey and John Wimber on The Alpha Course
Nicky Gumbel to Alpha Course Attendees: "Go Back to Your Catholic Parish"
Hopeless Hindu Ceremony Seeks to Wash Away Sins Without the Blood of the Lamb


  1. "Spiritual Directors"? They're described in the Bible in Matthew 23. Jeremiah 5 also sheds some light on the qualities of these men.

    Matthew 23:5-8, 13, 15, 27-28 (NAS)
    5 "But they do all their deeds to be noticed by men ; for they broaden their phylacteries and lengthen the tassels of their garments. 6 "They love the place of honor at banquets and the chief seats in the synagogues, 7 and respectful greetings in the market places, and being called Rabbi by men. 8 "But do not be called Rabbi ; for One is your Teacher, and you are all brothers. 13 "But woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, because you shut off the kingdom of heaven from people ; for you do not enter in yourselves, nor do you allow those who are entering to go in. 15 "Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, because you travel around on sea and land to make one proselyte ; and when he becomes one, you make him twice as much a son of hell as yourselves. 27 "Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites ! For you are like whitewashed tombs which on the outside appear beautiful, but inside they are full of dead men's bones and all uncleanness. 28 "So you, too, outwardly appear righteous to men, but inwardly you are full of hypocrisy and lawlessness.

    Jeremiah 5:31 (NAS)
    The prophets prophesy falsely, And the priests rule on their own authority; And My people love it so!


  2. Hi Erin, I was reading the list on "spiritual disciplines" and a few of them sound biblical. I was wondering if you have any info that delineates on each of these disciplines - what Foster actually means by them so I can understand why they are unbiblical.


    1. Hi Linda,

      This article probably provides the best summary of some of the dangers and where my concerns lie.

    2. Thanks Erin for being so kind as to take time out of your day to help me. I appreciate you

      Bob DeWaay and Gary Gilley's statements line up with my concerns as well which is very encouraging

      I don't know much about Richard Foster. But the fact that he uses writings from Monks who gain their wisdom from extra-biblical literature from the "Desert Fathers and Mothers" (should be) an instant red flag to Christians and outright rejection of such unbiblical material that is diametrically opposed to the word of God and wisdom already revealed in Christ.

      Every single cult has one thing in common-extra-biblical materials, and "revelations" outside the word of God. If they would just look at the last jot in the bible it ends with a period! -2 Timothy 3:16-17.

      This is very dangerous since it appeals to the flesh and has the "appearance of wisdom" that one can achieve and work for a righteousness of their own that will please God through some kind of man-made "spiritual disciplines". What they fail to realize is that there's only ONE righteousness God accepts and that's the righteousness of Christ. It's "in the GOSPEL that this "righteousness of God is revealed"-Romans 1:17 and it's by "Faith" not by "works" of asceticism-it's at the cross where God justifies the sinner.

      It's not hidden in some 14th century spiritual disciplines book and it's not "learned" by some journey--Romans 10:6-9

      And, we don't need some "enlightened teacher" or "spiritual director" to be our mediator when we can go directly and boldly to God's throne of grace because he's our Abba Daddy. I don't need to go to some secretary first to get to my Heavenly Father. Nor would I believe some writings of a desert hermit above my heavenly Father's -God's word is sufficient and true. 1 John 2:20.

  3. Thank you for standing up for Truth and standing against heresy.

    Can you please write a post about Jen Hatmaker. She is an up and coming author and is staring to take the Christian woman's world by storm because she homeschools and her and her husband have adopted children from Africa. She has over 19,600 followers on facebook.

    I want to warn my friends about her and so far this is what I have been able to find. (Unfortunately it will not be enough, in the past I have tried to warn people in my former church but nobody has heeded my warnings and now they just hired a contemplative scurrilous shepherd-- hence why it is my former church).

    Jen Hatmaker has been influenced by the book Sacrilegious by Hugh Halter http://www.jenhatmaker.com/blog/2012/07/16/jens-must-reads-part-1 Some huge red flags I found for Hugh Halter is he practices yoga and the authors he reads and promotes. “I gave it to several people in my yoga class….I have been deeply formed by Dallas Willard and his classic book, The Divine Conspiracy. I am invigorated daily by the British theologian NT Wright, and I love books that show real Christianty in church form, like The Barefoot Church by Brandon Hatmaker [Jenn's husband].” http://www.patheos.com/blogs/takeandread/2012/03/sacrilege-a-qa-with-hugh-halter/ Brandon is also involved in a ministry with Hugh Halter—Missio http://www.missio.us/our-team.htm

    Jen has also spoken the Emergent conference: Catalyst.http://catalystconference.com/Jen_Hatmaker
    Here is a link to her books from Amazon:

    Thank you.

    1. Hi Anonymous,

      I am not familiar with Jen Hatmaker, but I will take a look at the links you've provided.

    2. quote "Foster over the course of the past thirty years" ,,-"believes that even a non-believer in Christ can participate in the “spiritual discipline” of silence and have an encounter with God. The assumption by all mystics is that God dwells in all people, and meditation will help them to realize their own Divinity. This panentheistic view of God is very typical for contemplatives. As Ray Yungen points out, those who practice contemplative prayer begin to view God through panentheistic (God in all) and interspiritual (all is united) eyes. Thomas Merton, whom Foster has admired publicly for many years, believed that all human beings have divinity within, and this divinity can be accessed through contemplative prayer, thereby making the Cross of Jesus unnecessary for union with God. We believe that the reason for this change in spiritual outlook for those who continue practicing contemplative meditation (i.e., mantra-like meditation) is that these altered states of consciousness actually engage the practitioner with demonic realms leading to spiritual deception.

      quote ,,"the co-founder of one of the largest centers for teaching contemplative prayer, Tilden Edwards of The Shalem Institute, said that contemplative prayer is “the Western bridge to Far Eastern spirituality” (Edwards, Spiritual Friend, p. 18)."

      quotes from the article @-http://thereformedtraveler.com/2010/08/18/why-women-want-moore-special-report-from-lighthouse-trails/


Please keep it pithy (in other words, if your comment is long enough to be its own blog post, don't bother), pertinent (please don't go off-topic), and respectful (to the author, to the other readers, and to the subject of the post). If you can't do that, your comment will not be posted.

If you haven't already, please read the Comment Policy in its entirety.