22 December 2011

Beth Moore Recommends "Jesus Calling"

The following was written by Pastor-Teacher Ken Silva of Apprising Ministries:


by Ken Silva Pastor-Teacher
The largely pretending to be Protestant evangelical community continues its pilgrimage back to the legalistic spiritual bondage of apostate Roman Catholicism and its evil author the Church of Rome.
As an online apologetics and discernment work Apprising Ministries does what we can to document this woeful walk away from the truths recaptured during the Lord’s Reformation.
How sad He must be to see James Robison And Rick Warren Working To Reverse The Protestant Reformation. Bottom line is this: If sinful ecumenicists like Robison and Warren are right, then the Reformers were wrong.
Beyond question Southern Baptist Bible teacher Beth Moore still remains enormously popular within today’s anything goes evanjellyfish.
Not unlike charismatic megachurch pastors such as PDL Pope Rick Warren, Moore is also an SBC figure apparently receiving direct revelations from God. As I’ve been pointing out lately, this kind of thing is becoming a real problem in evangelicalism as virtually every other sentence or two out of the mouths of e.g. Rick Warren or Beth Moore is “God told me” this or “the Lord said” that to me.
The main point being, we’re finding ourselves heading right into the very type of neo-Gnosticism that so infected the theology of the Church of Rome that it would anathematize the very Gospel of Jesus Christ. This liver shiver theology, where doctrine is being decided by what someone feels God is saying rather than by what the Bible tells us God has said, has also given rise to attractional Prophet-Führers like Steven Furtick.
We’re reaching the point in the mainstream of the visible church where charismania is beginning to rule the day, which is going to lead to our having to deal with dueling revelations. Oddly enough, the Southern Baptist Convention, which seems to stand for Slowly Becoming Catholic (SBC) is said to frown upon charismatic practices; but I guess they’re okay as long as someone isn’t a Calvinist. I mean we can’t have that.
Yet aside from Warren and Moore in the SBC, for example, there’s the neo-Gnostic Henry Blackaby. His mysticism-lite Experiencing God mythology has attained near Scripture-like status within. This is another area where the SBC Idol of Autonomy comes in so handy; leaders simply hide behind it and say nothing. Some talk about how autonomy of the local church stops when proper Biblical doctrine is violated, but that’s all it is.
At this point I remind you again that the work of Beth Moore has received quite a boost from the aforementioned ecumenicist James Robison. Every Wednesday she appears on Robison’s LIFE Today—TV program in a segment entitled Wednesdays With Beth. Right now that website is “getting a makeover” so the segments are currently found at LightSource:
What is the concern here is the book that Beth Moore recommends for her followers this past Wednesday December 14, 2011:
You may also find it interesting to know that Jesus Calling (JC) by Sarah Young, which is said to be “Devotions for Every Day of the Year,” is published by Thomas Nelson publishing:
As I pointed out previously, in the case of Beth Moore and JC, this is not a matter of guilt-by-association, this is guilt-by-endorsement. Moore is absolutely recommending Sarah Young who is herself making the clear claim that she has received direct revelation from God and Jesus; though in a postmodern fashion she insists it’s really not. It kind of depends what audience she’s speaking with and the direction of the theological winds.
For example, Young tells us in her Introduction:
I began seeking God’s Presence in earnest. My days started alone with God, equipped with Bible, devotional book, prayer journal, pen, and coffee. As I waited in His Presence, God began to reveal Himself to me.[1]
You hear that type of language in charismatic and mystic circles, which are now overlapping with the spread of neo-Gnostic so-called “spiritual disciplines” of Contemplative Spirituality/Mysticism (CSM) under the guise of supposed Spiritual Formation. However, this is a form of divination, the occult; it is the attempt to gain knowledge of God outside of the Bible, a means of grace He has prescribed as the way to come to Him.
Beth Moore is on record below including herself among those who practice the crown jewel of CSM; a form of meditation in an altered state of consciousness commonly known as Contemplative/Centering Prayer (CCP):
In fact, CSM and CCP are the same practices employed by apostate Roman Catholic mystics. It’s a very dangerous thing to do because God reveals the only means by which we can legitimately come to Him; and so-called “listening” isn’t part of them. With this in mind, some time ago CBN ran Q & A with Sarah Young where she’s asked how she learned “to ‘dialogue’ with God?”
Her answer should disturb you:
My journey began with a devotional book (God Calling) written in the 1930′s by two women who practiced waiting in God’s Presence, writing the messages they received as they “listened.” About a year after I started reading this book, I began to wonder if I too could receive  messages during my times of communing with God. (Online source)
There’s nowhere in the Bible that we’re taught about waiting in God’s Presence in order to write personal messages we allegedly receive from God. The lives of the writers of inspired Scripture are not normative for the Christian. In fact, this all begins to sound like what’s known as occultic automatic writing; and yet, Young still tells us “this little paperback became a treasure to me.”[2]
However, these two women listeners tell us they were personally receiving direct revelations from God Himself to instruct them, unlike us mere mortals who go to Scripture:
with my friend a very wonderful thing happened.  From the first, beautiful messages were given to her from the Lord Himself, and every day from then these messages have never failed us.
We felt all unworthy and overwhelmed by the wonder of it, and could hardly realize that we were being taught, trained and encouraged day by day by Him personally, when millions of souls who are  far worthier, had to be content with guidance from the Bible, sermons, their Churches, books and other sources.[3]
As you can plainly see, they do claim divine inspiration for their writings; and like her listening mentors, so does Sarah Young. CBN asks her how “awkward was it initially to begin a ‘dialogue” with God?” Young replies:
It felt a little awkward the first time I tried it, but I did receive a short message… at that point my journaling changed from monologue to dialogue. Day by day, messages began to flow more freely. This new way of communicating with God became the high point of my day.
(Online source)
Now she realizes she’s describing divine inspiration for her messages so Young tries to add this caveat, “I knew that my writings were not inspired (as only Scripture is).” But she can’t have it both ways; when God speaks, it is Scripture. Or are we supposed to believe He also speaks non-authoritatively. Here the following from my friend Dr. Gary Gilley will prove helpful when he tells us people like Sarah Young:
would claim that while they believe that God speaks to His people apart from the Bible today, that these revelations are not on par with Scripture. That is, God speaks today but not with the same authority as He did in His Word. So do not accuse us of adding to Scripture, they would say.
Interestingly enough, this brings up another issue. We find in the Bible that God did speak, either orally (including through His prophets) or through the written Word, but in both ways — always,His Word is authoritative. It was nothing less than a word from God — one that must be obeyed and heeded! (Online source, emphasis his)
Like I said before, that supposedly conservative Southern Baptist Bible teacher Beth Moore would recommend her readers buy this book by Sarah Young ought to be cause for serious concern about her discernment. In his review of Jesus Calling Tim Challies now gets to the heart of the matter concerning this kind of neo-Gnosticism of these supposedly superior listeners:
As I have spoken to others about the book, I’ve heard some people say that this book is written as if Jesus is speaking to the reader. But it’s important to know that Young makes a far more audacious claim—this is Jesus speaking, through her. The messages he has given her, she now passes on to us.
This is a very good time to pause and consider this claim. Sarah is claiming some kind of new revelation from God. She is saying that God speaks to her and that she then passes these messages to others. Immediately we need to ask what she believes about the Bible. Is she claiming that these messages are equal to Scripture? That they trump Scripture?…
Young begins to share those words of God as daily devotionals, saying “I have continued to receive personal messages from God as I meditate on Him. The more difficult my life circumstances, the more I need these encouraging directives from my Creator.”
James Montgomery Boice once said that the real battle in our times would not be the inerrancy or infallibility of Scripture, but its sufficiency—are we going to rely on the Bible or will we continually long for other revelation? In Jesus Calling we see this so clearly. Young teaches that though the Bible is inerrant and infallible, it is insufficient. It was not enough for her and, implicitly, she teaches that it cannot be enough for us…
Jesus Calling is, in its own way, a very dangerous book. Though the theology is largely sound enough, my great concern is that it teaches that hearing words directly from Jesus and then sharing these words with others is the normal Christian experience. In fact, it elevates this experience over all others. And this is a dangerous precedent to set. I see no reason that I would ever recommend this book. (Online source)
Again, quite obviously, Beth Moore does not agree with this sound Biblical position expressed by Tim Challies.
End notes:
[1] Young, Sarah (2004-10-12). Jesus Calling: Seeking Peace in His Presence . Thomas Nelson. Kindle Edition. (Location 658).
[2] Ibid.


  1. Jesus told me to tell Beth to stop recommending the Jesus Calling book. So I will just write that down and mail it to Beth and that should take care of the problem.

  2. LOL, Anonymous. We all appreciate you taking care of this problem!

  3. I appreciate your posting this information. Beth Moore is leading many astray and there are not many warnings. Thank you for taking an unpopular stand.


  4. Beth Moore is so special, I wonder when she will be told that I Tim. 2:12 does not apply to her, then all us guys can be deceived along with her faithful followers of the female persuasion.-----never did like her, now I know why!


  5. When I was first saved in 1997, we did some Beth Moore bible studies and she was okay then.. But I was a new baby in Christ.

    NOW, she seems so superficial and caught up in all kinds of nonsense. I cannot believe what I am hearing come out of her mouth. She's sounding like WOF people now.

    I'm not saying whether she's saved or not I don't know her heart. But I'm certain we are going to be in for a SHOCK when we find out.

    I'm afraid this spotlight driven life has caused many a Christians to be ruined

    She needs to repent and I pray she does

  6. I have always thought that she seemed "manic" and oppressive. It was interesting to watch that short clip where she speaks about discernment and a critical spirit. It was an "argument" set up to "cover" herself from being challenged about error., i.e., if you challenge her regarding her experiences and doctrine it must be because YOU have a critical spirit.

    It is SO sad to see what's going on.

  7. Not sure about this book being largely sound. At first glance I thought the same thing. However, the use of snippets of scripture misquoted so abundantly and then used in the midst of another sentence is never something to be taken lightly. The scripture quotations used do NOT match up with what is said on each daily devotion. And there are some significant heresies here. See page 318. "learn to listen to Me even while you are listening to other people. As they open their souls to your scrutiny, you are on holy ground". Exodus 3:5 is listed at the bottom of the Page, the story of the burning bush. Wow! She seems to be claiming here that God is actually present as He was back then? Hmmm. Then page 329..."Focus your entire being on My Living Presence. I am most assuredly with you, enveloping you( there's that term again as used in preface when she speaks of her "conversion" and I think more of a new age term) in My Love and Peace. While you relax in My Presence, I am molding your mind and cleansing your heart. I am recreating you into the one I designed you to be". There is no mention here of Christs sacrifice or repentance. There is so much to be concerned about in this "devotional" that it's difficult to know where to start. Although it appears innocuous at first read, it is rife with false teaching.

  8. Wow. I have have been concerned about the blind devotion encouraged by the SBC on Beth Moore. I have avoided her conferences because I cringe at choreographed spiritual experiences. I believe that I have the "gift " of discernment, interesting in light of her comments. Our family was deeply involved in SBC churches for years, and I now see how far it has led many astray. This Jesus Calling foolishness is truly scary, though because she has released a child's version! I am infuriated that so many are being fooled, and recommending because celebrity Christians are recommending each others drivel. Time to wake up the bride!!! Thank you for this website!

  9. I have spoken against Bethe Moore on line and at my church [SB],
    it amazes the hurt feelings I encounter there. It does seem that
    too many people haven't been given the gift of discernment.

  10. This is more of the same New Age HOG WASH. And all of this is and should be no surprise at all. We that study the Word of GOD know these are just the signs of the times. So stay in the Word.

  11. My first visit to this website and some resistances I had in two different bible studies back in the 2001 to 2003 time frame are confirmed. I tried like the dickens to "get into" a Beth Moore bible group book as well as the Blackaby Experiencing God but I could not put a finger on why I would shiver/cringe at what I was reading.

    I had been a Christian saved many years but was really undergoing to some personal trials facing failure and financial difficulties. I so wanted to have these two books help me but I could not stand them. I actually destroyed both of the books, something I never do to books, being a book lover.

    I'm just amazed this is now confirmed to me more than 10 years later.

    1. Sadly my own local conservative baptist church has been taken over by the end of days new age "you must be still and listen for Jesus" false doctrine. What makes it all worse? = The elder board has co-operated. Those that questioned anything? Were eliminated.

  12. I walk fully in sync with those who see BM as dangerous to the Body. I find her at best a sloppy student of the Word and far too often a diligent mis-handler of God's Word in the service of some dictate she 'feels' has importance for her audience.

    Yet . . . I remain confused about the role many of her critics see for the Christian's obedience to the Word and will of God. Any (even passing) reference by BM to what we 'need' to do as Christians or mention by her of our call as Christians to obey God's will as stated in the text throws her critics into spasms of rage about her turn to Roman Catholic legalism.

    Hmmm . . . Christ and Paul have LOTS to say to saved-by-faith-not-works Christians about what they 'need' to do and about the value of obeying Christ, His example and words, once they're saved by grace. To be sure, the motive for such obedience moves from earning salvation or God's praise (impossible) gratitude, love, a desire to please the One who gave His life for us.

    I feel BM's critics have enough legitimate targets for their alarm that they can be a little more careful about the legitimate place for obedience in the effective and anointed and saved-by-faith Christian life. Times are tough enough without being bracketed by BM's on one side and near-hysterical, would-be purifiers of the Faith on the other side.

    Please advise.


Please keep it pithy (in other words, if your comment is long enough to be its own blog post, don't bother), pertinent (please don't go off-topic), and respectful (to the author, to the other readers, and to the subject of the post). If you can't do that, your comment will not be posted.

If you haven't already, please read the Comment Policy in its entirety.